Category Archives: Good Question

How do young Indian Americans navigate the traditional expectations of arranged marriages?

By Allyna Mota Melville, Medill, Immigrant Connect

[Read related Immigrant Connect stories – Arranged marriage: A tradition endures among Indian-Americans and Digital disruption: Arranged marriages adapt for Indian Americans]

Most American kids don’t want their parents to have any hand in their love lives. In India, however, it’s almost expected.

Karishma Naha*, a sophomore at Cornell University in Ithaca, NY, respects her parents’ story. Their marriage was arranged. That doesn’t mean it’s for her.

“They pretty much said they would be good with marrying each other after two to three months of getting to know each other,” Naha says. Her parents, from Andhra Pradesh, India, immigrated to the United States more than twenty years ago. She and her nine-year-old sister have lived in the U.S. all their lives, and are keenly aware of the cultural differences in having parents married in what has become to them an unconventional way.

“The stigma [of getting married without parental involvement] makes sense—it’s an uncomfortable thing to do,” Naha says. “My aunt, even after twenty-plus years, still hates her husband only because she believes she was forced into the marriage.”

Raj Naha*, her father, sees a greater mobility in the arrangement process now than there was in his time—especially through India’s centuries-old caste system.

Shaadi.com, The World’s No.1 Matchmaking Service prides itself on addressing the ways find people happiness, and redefining how Indian brides and grooms meet for marriage, Click on the photo to go to the website.

“[The caste] is traditionally based on who you are, and what your social practice or profession is,” Raj Naha says. “Within the very specific caste, it revolves around an expectation of different milestones in your life.” One of these, he says, was marriage.

Typically, these marriages would occur within a specific area, so there are similar behaviors with respect to religion and food—and these hold the strongest power in a match. However, Raj Naha says, this process is community driven and non-binding.

“It’s arranging to see if there’s something there, and then the parents take a back seat,” he explains. “It makes sure that 87 percent of the process is already taken care of.”

Looking to his daughters, Raj Naja would like to keep some of the more casual aspects of the approved match system, mainly that he knows who the man is.

“He can be Indian or non-Indian … and I would love to know the families and I do not see that as a wrong thing,” he says.

“My parents have never pressured me into thinking I need to have an arranged marriage,” Karishma Naha adds. “There aren’t many ‘matches’ out there that my mom approves of anyways.”

Priyanka Godbole, a Northwestern sophomore, doesn’t anticipate that an arranged marriage is in her future. Her parents, who have been married since 1995, met in a way she describes as “speed dating.”

Her parents’ parents were like her parents who “met with a bunch of people to see who they would get along with,” Godbole says. “When it happened, it was super fast—they went on dates for a month and then they got married.”

Like the Nahas, Godbole says her parents take a back seat on her love life.

“They know I’m basically white,” Godbole jokes. “They pretty much tell me I can do anything I want.” Even when “boys are being dumb,” they refuse to intervene with any arranging.

“It isn’t really a big thing except for in rural India,” Godbole says.

However, 74 percent of young Indians prefer an arranged marriage over a free-choice one, according to a story in India Today that cited a survey by IPSOS, an international consulting firm. Raj Naha sees this as nearly unchangeable, saying that “it’s in the DNA.”

“This doesn’t change this quickly. There is no revolution against arranged marriages,” he says. “The hybrid system is the best of both worlds … flexibility with avoiding some unknowns.”

The prevalence of the practice on the Indian subcontinent is not lost on Karishma Naha.

“My mom still actively looks for matches for my cousin [who lives in India],” she says. “I definitely think that if we grew up there, she would be doing the same for me.

———–

*Some of the names have been changed to respect people’s privacy.

Are Indian parents doing anything differently since Trump’s election?

By Amit Mallik, Medill, Immigrant Connect “Mom, are we going to be kicked out because we’re brown?” Aarush came back home from first grade at his Salt Lake City school in February, just a few days after Donald Trump was elected President, and expressed genuine concern to his mom, Litty Paul, who immigrated to the… Continue Reading

What do adults who enter the U.S. legally, but who recognize they may remain beyond their short-term visas, do in the first few weeks after coming into the country, in terms of connecting with people and planning for the future? What type of planning is needed before they come?

By Sidney I. Thomas, Medill, Immigrant Connect Imagine coming to a country where the national language is not your native one, a country where you have no family, and where you are constantly in fear of being detained and sent back if you’ve been found to overstay your welcome. This is the case for thousands… Continue Reading

Women often come to the U.S. and become nannies. What’s it like taking care of someone else’s family and leaving yours behind?

By Balim Tezel, Medill, Immigrant Connect Rosa Contreras made one of the hardest decisions of her life 12 years ago after realizing that the decision might be the only way to give her kids the life they deserve. The Ecuadorian mother said goodbye to her kids. She didn’t know how to make her kids feel… Continue Reading

What are the options for young Syrians hoping to pursue an education in the United States?

By Nora Shelly, Medill, Immigrant Connect Elias Shammas says he is the “luckiest” of his fellow Syrian students at Monmouth College in western Illinois. Shammas was born in the United States, but grew up in Damascus, Syria. A little more than a year after the civil war started in March of 2011, Shammas’ younger sister… Continue Reading

Aren’t there Canadians and Mexicans who work in the U.S? How do they do it?

By Brian Hofmann, Medill, Immigrant Connect Patti Kunkel’s schedule mirrors that of most nurse practitioners in her field. In the car by 5 a.m., she begins her half-hour commute to work at Henry Ford Hospital in Midtown, Detroit by picking up a cup of coffee. However, Patti’s commute is different. She crosses the border, and… Continue Reading

Are more immigrants signing up to take citizenship classes following Donald Trump’s election?

By Isabella Soto, Medill, Immigrant Connect The soft sound of chalk traveling across the deep green chalkboard fills the room. Flakes of white talc float down to the floor. “Independence day,” one student writes. “In the pendence day,” writes another. After reflecting on his spelling for a moment, he laughs, then uses the back of… Continue Reading